Abstract:
On April 1, 2021,Ā theĀ Biden Administration announced that Secretary of Education Michael Cardona will consider whetherĀ theĀ President has legal authority to forgive up to $50,000 per debtor in student loan debt without further Congressional action. This paper collectsĀ theĀ leading arguments for and againstĀ theĀ position thatĀ theĀ Biden Administration can forgive this student loan debt as an administrative action and without additional congressional authorization.Ā TheĀ paper first surveysĀ theĀ history of federal student loan forgiveness programs inĀ theĀ United States.Ā TheĀ paper then considers whether statutes onĀ theĀ booksāin particular,Ā theĀ Higher Education Act of 1965 andĀ theĀ Federal Claims Collection Act of 1966āgrantĀ theĀ executiveĀ branchĀ theĀ authority to effect widespread student loan forgiveness.Ā TheĀ paper considers howĀ theĀ Department of Education might use administrative action to forgive loans and assessesĀ theĀ pros and cons ofĀ theĀ Department proceeding without notice and comment rulemaking. Finally,Ā theĀ paper evaluatesĀ theĀ Biden Administrationās prospects in court, including whether any parties would have standing to challenge administrative student loan forgiveness and which forms of administrative action are likeliest to survive judicial review.
Commentary:
This article provides strong arguments for both finding that USED has authority to forgive student loan debt and also that it is not permitted to do so. The obstacles to student loan discharge by executive order are significant, with real risk that such forgiveness could later be undone.
Unfortunately, the article does not also consider whether USED has authority to consent to the discharge of student loans in an Adversary Proceeding in a bankruptcy case. That USED and its servicers have occasionally, albeit rarely, consented to such in the past indicates that this is permitted and USED could, by extension, provide clear and more generous "safe harbors" to allow debtors to not only obtain discharges but better predict that prior to filing bankruptcy. Further, while this article argues that the Federal Claims Collection Act of 1966 (FCCA) does not allow executive action to compromise performing debts, the filing of bankruptcy is a reasonable indicator that the student loan is no longer performing, especially since payments during a Chapter 13 plan would be no greater than under an Income Driven Repayment (IDR) plan and likely less. This has, in fact, been argued for in the article A No-Contest Discharge for Uncollectible Student Loans and also by NACBA in the response to the USED Request for Information on Evaluating Undue Hardship Claims in Adversary Actions Seeking Student Loan Discharge in Bankruptcy Proceedings
For a copy, please click here:
May the Executive Branch Forgive Student Loan Debt Without Further Congressional Action?
Blog comments