Summary and Commentary (In re Gilbert, W.D.N.C. 2025)

Russell Wade Gilbert filed his third Chapter 13 case in just over fourteen months, all pro se and without an attorney. His first case (June 2024) was dismissed for failure to propose a feasible plan, make initial payments, and file required tax returns. His second case (November 2024) was dismissed in July 2025 for defaulting on plan payments. Just six weeks later, he filed the present case in August 2025.

Summary:

Summary:

Judge Kenneth D. Bell’s denial of Navient’s motion for summary judgment in Ready v. Navient (W.D.N.C. No. 5:24-cv-00050) is a sharp reminder that even student loan creditors must prove the underlying debt. Navient insisted that Ms. Christy Ready had taken out a 1995 consolidation loan through “Citibank (NYS)” which was later rolled into a 2002 consolidation. Ms.

Summary:

Summary:

Summary:

Summary:

Summary:

Summary:

Summary: