Skip to main content
Home

Main navigation

  • NC Bankruptcy Cases
    • Eastern District
    • Middle District
    • Western District
  • NC Courts
    • 4th Circuit Court of Appeals
    • NC Court of Appeals
    • NC Business Court
    • NC Supreme Court Cases
  • Federal Cases
  • Law Reviews & Studies
    • Book Reviews
  • NC Legislative History
  • Student Loan Debt
User account menu
  • Log in

Breadcrumb

  1. Home
  2. Blogs

Law Review: Simon, Lindsey, The Settlement Trap (March 16, 2021). Indiana Law Journal, Forthcoming, University of Georgia School of Law Legal Studies Research Paper No. 2021-16

Profile picture for user Ed Boltz
By Ed Boltz, 12 December, 2021

Abstract:

Mass tort victims often wait years for resolution of their personal injury claims, but many who successfully navigate this arduous process will not receive a single dollar of their settlement award. According to applicable bankruptcy and state law, settlement payments may be an asset of the estate that the trustee, exercising its significant authority, administers and distributes to creditors instead of a claimant who had filed for bankruptcy. This distribution power maximizes repayment, a critical counterbalance to the robust protections and benefits that debtors receive in bankruptcy.

Setting aside the perceived unfairness of taking desperately needed money from tort victims, there is something fundamentally unsettling about the process by which bankruptcy law ensnares payment of mass tort settlements. This Article is the first to identify the problem, which it dubs the “settlement trap.” Claimants in the settlement trap must seek relief from the mass tort claims administrator, the trustee, and potentially the bankruptcy court, facing costs and legal challenges at each turn. This Article explores the developing law surrounding treatment of mass tort settlements in consumer bankruptcy and identifies structural and doctrinal pressure points that impose significant confusion and costs on claimants. It supplements legal analysis with original interviews of stakeholders in the ongoing NFL concussion and pelvic mesh cases, case studies that highlight the peculiar mix of incentives that impact whether claimants receive their settlements and illustrate the potential for abuse. Finally, the Article offers a blueprint for reform.

Commentary:

The author is very astute in recognizing that this problem is compounded by "various causes and contributing factors", including:

-The “gang of lawyers” in mass tort cases who have too much control in the process and not enough bankruptcy knowledge,

-The claims administrators that increase costs “out of the claimant’s pockets,”

-The “money-grabber” trustees who “shake down” claimants for their settlement awards

Solutions suggested include judicial "recalibrations" of how personal injury and mass tort awards are understood not to be piles of cash, but long-term disability compensation, which is generally provided with more generous exemptions. Additionally, legislation on the state or federal levels could both clarify when these settlement are assets of the estate and provide greater exemptions.

Relatedly, the Executive Office of the U.S. Trustee (or in North Carolina and Alabama, the Bankruptcy Administrators) could issue guidance and directives to Trustees to clarify and limit when these are taken, including that the trustee’s ability to settle litigation should not be the detriment of the debtor’s interest in exemptions or surplus. That the U.S. Trustee program itself, when it came to the multiple mass tort mortgage settlements a decade ago, failed to take the impact and benefits to the debtors harmed (and often driven into bankruptcy) by bankrupt mortgage servicers does not lend much hope for this improvement.

For a copy of this article, please see:

The Settlement Trap

Blog comments

Blog tags
bankruptcy
exemption
Trustee
Chapter 7
Category
Law Reviews & Studies

About Us

Mountain View The purpose of the NC Bankruptcy Expert blog is to provide legal professionals with a consolidated resource for updates and case summaries about issues and decisions affecting bankruptcy, foreclosures, mortgages, and debt collection.

 
Lawyer Edward Boltz | Top Attorney Chapter 7

NC Bankruptcy Expert FREE Consultation

We Offer A Free Bankruptcy Consultation which has helped over 70,000 North Carolina families. We serve the entire state of North Carolina.

Proud Member of:












Categories

  • 4th Circuit Court of Appeals
  • Book Reviews
  • District Courts
  • Eastern District
  • Ed Boltz: Bankruptcy Attorney
  • Federal Cases
  • Forms
  • Home
  • Law Reviews & Studies
  • Middle District
  • Mortgage Modification Mediation Documents
  • NC Business Court
  • NC Court of Appeals
  • NC Courts
  • NC Supreme Court Cases
  • News
  • North Carolina Bankruptcy Cases
  • North Carolina District Court Cases
  • North Carolina Exemptions Legislative History
  • Student Loan Debt
  • Student Loan Options and Chapter 13 Bankruptcy
  • Western District
RSS feed
v. 1.2.2, © 2013-2025 ncbankruptcyexpert.com, all rights reserved. Follow @edboltz