Skip to main content
Home

Main navigation

  • NC Bankruptcy Cases
    • Eastern District
    • Middle District
    • Western District
  • NC Courts
    • 4th Circuit Court of Appeals
    • NC Court of Appeals
    • NC Business Court
    • NC Supreme Court Cases
  • Federal Cases
  • Law Reviews & Studies
    • Book Reviews
  • NC Legislative History
  • Student Loan Debt
User account menu
  • Log in

Breadcrumb

  1. Home
  2. Blogs

4th Cir.: Talley v. Folwell- Overpayment of State Retirement

Profile picture for user Ed Boltz
By Ed Boltz, 7 May, 2025

Summary:

In Talley v. Folwell, the Fourth Circuit affirmed the dismissal of constitutional claims brought by retired North Carolina teacher Patsy Talley, who had received over $86,000 in retirement overpayments due to a longstanding administrative error. When the Teachers’ and State Employees’ Retirement System (TSERS) discovered the error eight years later, it began recouping the overpaid amount through a reduction in Talley’s monthly benefits. Talley did not dispute the overpayment but alleged that the state violated her due process and equal protection rights by reducing her benefits without a prior hearing or clear standards governing recoupment procedures.

The district court dismissed most of Talley’s claims, holding that Eleventh Amendment immunity barred her official-capacity claims and that the individual defendants were protected by qualified immunity. The court also found her equal protection and substantive due process claims failed to state a plausible constitutional violation. The Fourth Circuit agreed, finding that any alleged lack of pre-deprivation process was cured by a post-deprivation hearing before an administrative law judge. The court emphasized that the recoupment process was rational and statutorily authorized, and that Talley had not shown a clearly established constitutional right requiring a hearing before benefit reductions in this context. Her motion to amend the complaint to add new plaintiffs was also denied as untimely and procedurally deficient.

Commentary:

If TSERS merely made an administrative error (as appears to be the case here), and there is no allegation that Talley knew about the overpayments or fraudulently induced them, then no § 523(a) exception would appear to apply, and the debt would be dischargeable in bankruptcy.  

This raises the next critical issue: even if the overpayment is discharged, TSERS may argue for a right of recoupment or setoff, which are equitable doctrines that allow deduction from ongoing payments even in bankruptcy.    N.C. Gen. Stat. § 135-9(b)   expressly allows  TSERS to recover overpayments by offsetting against future benefit payments.

If Talley was not receiving future payments from TSERS (e.g., if she had already taken a lump sum or otherwise separated from the system), then recoupment might not be possible, and the state would be limited to collection as a creditor—and being dischargeable without further ability to collect from other sources.

With proper attribution,  please share this post. 

Blog comments

Attachment
Document
talley_v._folwell.pdf (226.35 KB)
Category
4th Circuit Court of Appeals

About Us

Mountain View The purpose of the NC Bankruptcy Expert blog is to provide legal professionals with a consolidated resource for updates and case summaries about issues and decisions affecting bankruptcy, foreclosures, mortgages, and debt collection.

 
Lawyer Edward Boltz | Top Attorney Chapter 7

NC Bankruptcy Expert FREE Consultation

We Offer A Free Bankruptcy Consultation which has helped over 70,000 North Carolina families. We serve the entire state of North Carolina.

Proud Member of:












Categories

  • 4th Circuit Court of Appeals
  • Book Reviews
  • District Courts
  • Eastern District
  • Ed Boltz: Bankruptcy Attorney
  • Federal Cases
  • Forms
  • Home
  • Law Reviews & Studies
  • Middle District
  • Mortgage Modification Mediation Documents
  • NC Business Court
  • NC Court of Appeals
  • NC Courts
  • NC Supreme Court Cases
  • News
  • North Carolina Bankruptcy Cases
  • North Carolina District Court Cases
  • North Carolina Exemptions Legislative History
  • Student Loan Debt
  • Student Loan Options and Chapter 13 Bankruptcy
  • Western District
RSS feed
v. 1.2.2, © 2013-2025 ncbankruptcyexpert.com, all rights reserved. Follow @edboltz