Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=7597478
Abstract
This paper reviews and extends the literature on the costs and benefits of household debt relief. Debt relief transfers resources from creditors or taxpayers to debtors. This transfer can increase social welfare when households face incomplete markets. A lack of insurance against adverse events, such as job loss and illness, can be offset by the option to reduce debt payments. However, when debt relief imposes larger losses on creditors, possibly through borrower moral hazard, generous debt relief can reduce the supply of credit. Taxpayerfunded debt relief may also spur creditor moral hazard and inefficiently high lending if creditors do not fully internalize the cost of risky lending. Evidence for bankruptcy suggests that the insurance benefits outweigh the credit access costs. Through data and theory, I highlight parallels across different forms of debt relief that may guide future evaluations of optimal debt relief design.
Summary
In The Costs and Benefits of Household Debt Relief, Sasha Indarte examines the economic consequences of bankruptcy, delinquency, debt settlement, loan modifications, and government-sponsored debt relief, concluding that the benefits of consumer bankruptcy generally outweigh the costs associated with reduced access to credit.
The central argument is that bankruptcy serves as a form of insurance against financial catastrophes, including unemployment, illness, and other circumstances that households cannot adequately insure against.
While creditors may respond to more generous bankruptcy protections by restricting lending or increasing interest rates, the evidence suggests that these costs are outweighed by the economic benefits of allowing financially distressed households to obtain relief.
Several findings are particularly noteworthy:
1. Bankruptcy Is Primarily a Response to Financial Distress, Not Moral Hazard.
The argument that generous bankruptcy laws encourage irresponsible borrowing and strategic defaults receives little empirical support.
Indarte finds that increasing available bankruptcy relief by $1,000 raises the probability of filing by only 0.02 percentage points, while providing households with $1,000 in additional cash reduces filing probability by 0.09 percentage points.
In other words, lack of liquidity is a substantially greater driver of bankruptcy than the financial incentives to discharge debts.
Similarly, research on mortgage defaults attributes approximately 70% of defaults to income reductions rather than strategic decisions arising solely from negative home equity.
2. Bankruptcy Provides Substantial Economic Benefits to Debtors.
Research reviewed by Indarte estimates that, without bankruptcy, consumption for the marginal bankruptcy filer would be approximately 30% to 58% lower than with bankruptcy protection.
Bankruptcy also produces positive employment outcomes. One study found that receiving a Chapter 13 discharge increased annual earnings by approximately $5,562 and employment rates by 6.8 percentage points.
These benefits are particularly pronounced where creditors can garnish wages, suggesting that relief from debt collection can improve employment incentives and economic stability.
3. BAPCPA Substantially Reduced Access to Bankruptcy.
The 2005 Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act increased filing costs, documentation requirements, and restrictions on Chapter 7 eligibility.
Indarte cites research estimating that BAPCPA reduced bankruptcy filings by approximately 493,000 annually.
More strikingly, the combined financial and nonfinancial burdens imposed by BAPCPA were estimated to have an effect equivalent to increasing the cost of bankruptcy by approximately $11,812 per household.
While BAPCPA was associated with credit card interest rate reductions of approximately 0.70 to 0.90 percentage points, these relatively modest borrowing benefits came at the cost of substantially restricting bankruptcy relief.
4. Debt Settlement Can Make Financial Distress Worse.
Indarte's review is particularly critical of debt settlement programs.
Research cited in the paper found that out-of-court settlements increased subsequent delinquency by 20%, bankruptcy by 160%, and foreclosure by 130%.
One explanation is that settlements often require substantial immediate payments, potentially diverting money from housing, transportation, and other necessities.
Indeed, consumers entering settlements were found to pay nearly four times as much during the first year as they would have paid through garnishment.
5. Bankruptcy Can Benefit the Entire Economy.
Debt relief does more than improve the finances of individual households.
By allowing distressed consumers to maintain spending during recessions, bankruptcy helps stabilize economic demand, employment, and production.
Indarte cites research estimating that access to bankruptcy protections increased employment during the Great Recession by approximately 2% compared with what it otherwise would have been.
Bankruptcy therefore functions not merely as an individual remedy but also as an economic stabilizer.
Commentary
Indarte's paper provides substantial economic support for what consumer bankruptcy attorneys have long observed: most debtors do not file bankruptcy because they want to avoid paying their debts, but because circumstances have made repayment impossible or economically destructive.
The distinction between moral hazard and liquidity constraints is especially important.
Much of the justification for BAPCPA rested on the assumption that bankruptcy was too readily available and that consumers were abusing the system. Indarte's review suggests that the financial incentives to file are relatively weak compared with the consequences of job loss, illness, and other financial setbacks.
That raises serious questions about the wisdom of imposing extensive means testing, documentation requirements, mandatory counseling, and other procedural barriers on financially distressed households.
It is particularly telling that BAPCPA's estimated reduction in credit card interest rates was less than one percentage point, while the legislation imposed dramatically greater burdens on those needing bankruptcy protection.
The economic bargain appears decidedly unfavorable to consumers.
Bankruptcy Versus Debt Settlement
The findings regarding debt settlement are equally important for consumer attorneys.
Creditors regularly portray bankruptcy as an unnecessarily drastic remedy and encourage borrowers to pursue voluntary settlements instead.
Yet the research suggests that these settlements can actually worsen financial distress, particularly when substantial lump-sum payments deplete household liquidity.
Bankruptcy, by contrast, provides a comprehensive mechanism for addressing competing creditor claims, rather than allowing individual creditors to demand payments without regard to the debtor's obligations to others.
This is especially significant in Chapter 13, where a debtor can address unsecured debts while preserving funds for mortgages, vehicles, taxes, and ordinary living expenses.
It also supports the conclusion that bankruptcy should not automatically be treated as a last resort, to be considered only after debtors have exhausted their savings through unsuccessful settlement efforts.
Exemptions Are Economic Protections, Not Windfalls
Indarte also provides useful support for expanding bankruptcy exemptions.
Although more generous exemptions can theoretically increase creditor losses and affect credit availability, the research reviewed suggests that increasing exemption protections can improve overall social welfare.
Exemptions preserve the housing, transportation, household property, and other resources debtors need to remain economically productive.
The paper also identifies an interesting relationship: states with more generous homestead exemptions tend to have lower bankruptcy filing rates, although this correlation does not itself establish that exemptions cause fewer filings.
This undercuts the simplistic assumption that stronger debtor protections necessarily produce more bankruptcies.
For North Carolina, where exemption amounts have not always kept pace with the actual costs of housing, transportation, and household necessities, the broader lesson is that protecting property essential to a fresh start can benefit both individual debtors and the economy.
Creditor Moral Hazard Deserves Equal Attention
Another important aspect of Indarte's analysis is its recognition that moral hazard is not exclusively a debtor problem.
Government-sponsored modifications and creditor bailouts can encourage excessive lending when creditors expect taxpayers or other parties to absorb the consequences of poorly underwritten loans.
This is an important corrective to the frequent assumption that irresponsible borrowing, rather than irresponsible lending, is the principal source of consumer financial distress.
Bankruptcy policy should account for incentives on both sides of the lending relationship, particularly where creditors control underwriting standards, loan terms, and collection practices.
Indarte recognizes that the empirical evidence on creditor moral hazard arising specifically from government-sponsored modifications remains limited, but the concern is well worth further examination.
Consumer Bankruptcy Reform
Although published in April 2022, Indarte's analysis remains relevant to proposals to reform the consumer bankruptcy system, including the Consumer Bankruptcy Reform Act.
The paper provides economic support for reducing barriers to bankruptcy, strengthening exemptions, and treating debt relief as an essential component of household financial security rather than primarily as a mechanism for punishing default.
One further implication deserves emphasis: The success of consumer bankruptcy should not be measured solely by how much money creditors recover.
A bankruptcy system that allows debtors to retain employment, preserve housing, avoid foreclosure, and resume participation in the economy produces benefits that are not reflected in Chapter 7 liquidation distributions or Chapter 13 trustee disbursement statistics.
Similarly, a Chapter 13 case that is dismissed without discharge is not necessarily devoid of economic value, particularly if it allowed a family to retain its home, address an immediate financial emergency, or maintain employment. Indarte's paper does not directly measure those outcomes, but its economic framework supports considering them.
Ultimately, the most important conclusion is that bankruptcy is not simply a transfer of losses from debtors to creditors. It is a form of social insurance with benefits that extend beyond the individual debtor.
The economic evidence reviewed by Indarte suggests that restricting access to that insurance can impose considerably greater costs on households—and potentially on the broader economy—than the modest improvements in credit availability that restrictions may produce.
That should be a central consideration in any serious discussion of consumer bankruptcy reform.
To read a copy of the transcript, please see:
Blog comments